Home>Gift Ideas>Top Guitar Picks: A Comprehensive Review

Top Guitar Picks: A Comprehensive Review Top Guitar Picks: A Comprehensive Review

Gift Ideas

Top Guitar Picks: A Comprehensive Review

Written by: Bernardine Hutton

Discover the top guitar picks with our comprehensive review. Find the perfect pick to enhance your playing experience.

(Many of the links in this article redirect to a specific reviewed product. Your purchase of these products through affiliate links helps to generate commission for Giftslessordinary.com, at no extra cost. Learn more)

Are you in the market for a new guitar pick, but not sure where to start? Look no further than "Top Guitar Picks: A Comprehensive Review." In this review, we will take an in-depth look at some of the best guitar picks on the market, covering everything from material and thickness to durability and playability. Whether you're a beginner or a seasoned pro, this review is sure to help you find the perfect pick for your playing style. Keep reading to find out which picks come out on top!

Top Picks:

Overall Score: 9/10

The D'Addario Celluloid Guitar Picks come in a 10-pack and are suitable for acoustic, electric, and bass guitars. With a medium gauge of 0.70mm, these picks offer a natural feel and warm tone, catering to both strumming and articulate picking. The standard shape provides comfortable playing, making them an ideal gift for guitar players. The packaging is designed for minimal waste and environmental impact, making them a sustainable choice. These picks have received rave reviews for their quality and durability.

Key Features

  • 0.70MM Medium guitar pick
  • Natural feel & Warm tone
  • Comfortable playing
  • Packaging for minimal waste
  • Great gift for guitar players


  • Color: Assorted
  • Dimension: 5.00Lx3.00Wx1.00H
  • Size: 10-pack


  • Medium gauge suitable for various playing styles
  • Provides natural feel and warm, fat tone
  • Comfortable standard shape
  • Sustainable packaging design
  • Ideal gift for guitar players


  • All picks are 0.70mm, only assorted in colors

The D’Addario Celluloid Guitar Picks are a standout choice for guitar enthusiasts. With their versatile nature, comfortable design, and positive user feedback, these picks have proven their worth. Whether for casual strumming or intricate picking, these picks offer a natural feel and warm tone, making them a valuable addition to any guitarist’s collection.

Overall Score: 9/10

The 15 Pack Guitar Picks Plectrums come with an organizer storage box and includes thin, medium, and heavy thicknesses with a variety of colorful celluloid plectrums for bass electric and acoustic guitars, as well as ukuleles. Made of high quality celluloid, these picks are durable and come in multiple styles and colors to meet your specific playing needs. The clear plastic organizer box makes it easy to store and organize the picks, while the different thicknesses offer different tone colors for added versatility.

Key Features

  • 15 Pack assorted guitar picks with different colors and designs
  • 3 different thicknesses: 0.5mm, 0.75mm, 1.0mm
  • High quality celluloid material
  • Suitable for bass, ukulele, acoustic, or electric guitar
  • Clear plastic organizer box for easy storage


  • Color: Multicolor
  • Size: 15 Blend


  • Durable and high quality material
  • Variety of colors and designs
  • Convenient organizer storage box included
  • Different thicknesses for versatile tone


  • May not be suitable for those who prefer a single pick thickness

The 15 Pack Guitar Picks Plectrums with Organizer Storage Box is a versatile and high quality set of picks suitable for guitar and ukulele players of all levels. With a variety of colors, designs, and thicknesses, it offers a great value for musicians looking to enhance their playing experience.

Overall Score: 9/10

The Fender Premium Picks Sampler is a 12-pack set that includes thin, medium, and heavy gauges. Made from celluloid, these picks offer a warm, round music tone and are the 'go to' pick for many professional artists. They come in assorted colors and various styles to match your specific playing needs. Customers rave about the quality, variety, and durability of these guitar picks, making them a perfect gift for beginners or seasoned guitar players.

Key Features

  • Made from celluloid, the premier pick material
  • Offers a warm, round music tone
  • The 'go to' pick for many professional artists
  • Comes with Thin, Medium, and Heavy Gauges
  • Comes in many different styles and colors to match your specific playing needs – Try them all!


  • Color: Assorted
  • Dimension: 9.00L x 1.00W x 6.00H
  • Size: 12 Pack


  • Quality material and build
  • Variety of thickness options
  • Great for beginners and seasoned players
  • Color variations as pictured
  • Durable and long-lasting


  • May not appeal to players with specific pick preferences

The Fender Premium Picks Sampler – 12 Pack is a must-have for any guitarist. With its wide range of thickness options, durable build, and high-quality materials, it’s no wonder why both beginners and professionals love this set. Whether you’re looking for the perfect gift or expanding your own collection, these picks are a top choice. The only drawback is that players with very specific pick preferences may find the set less suitable.

Overall Score: 9/10

The 60 PCS Guitar Picks set offers a variety of plectrums in different thickness for bass, electric, and acoustic guitars. Made of high quality celluloid, these picks are durable and provide a warm and round musical tone. The wide body and rounded tip design prevents chipping and fits the finger perfectly, making it an ideal accessory for guitar enthusiasts.

Key Features

  • Material: High quality celluloid
  • Size: 20 picks each of 0.46mm, 0.71mm, 0.96mm
  • Advantage: Prevents chipping, fits finger perfectly
  • Function: Offers a warm and round musical tone
  • Application: Suitable for acoustic and electric guitars


  • Color: Multicolor
  • Dimension: 5.90Lx3.93Wx0.39H
  • Size: 3 Size


  • Durable and high quality materials
  • Various thickness for different playing styles
  • Prevents chipping and fits finger perfectly
  • Offers a warm and round musical tone
  • Suitable for both acoustic and electric guitars


  • Some users did not like the random color assortment

The 60 PCS Guitar Picks set provides great value for guitar enthusiasts, offering a variety of picks with different thickness and colors. The durability, quality, and versatile application make it an ideal choice for players of all levels. However, the random color assortment may not appeal to all users, but this does not take away from the overall value of this product.

Overall Score: 8.5/10

The Ernie Ball Everlast Guitar Picks, Purple 1.0mm, 12-pack (P09193) are designed for durability and a non-slip surface. With a purple 1.0mm gauge and made from Delrin, these guitar picks provide excellent grip and wear-resistance. This 12-pack is a great value and is perfect for guitarists who prefer a thicker pick. Customers have raved about the durability, grip, and overall quality of these picks, making them an excellent choice for musicians looking for reliable accessories.

Key Features

  • Purple 1.0mm gauge
  • Made from Delrin for a more secure, non-slip surface
  • Durable, wear-resistant Delrin material
  • Pack of 12 guitar picks


  • Color: Purple (1.0mm)
  • Dimension: 2.50Lx0.50Wx4.25H
  • Size: 0


  • Excellent durability and wear-resistance
  • Great grip and non-slip surface
  • Good value for a 12-pack


  • Some users may find the 0.60mm picks too stiff

The Ernie Ball Everlast Guitar Picks offer exceptional quality, durability, and value, making them a top choice for guitarists who need reliable picks for their performances or practice sessions.

Overall Score: 6/10

The I-MART Stylish Colorful Celluloid Guitar Picks Plectrums come in a pack of 12 assorted colors with a 0.46mm thickness. They are suitable for use with guitar, bass, or ukulele. The picks provide a natural feel and warm, round music tone. Made of celluloid, these picks have a classic guitar pick shape and are multicolored in random. Customers have reported mixed experiences with the picks, with some praising their quality and value, while others found them too thin and flimsy. The picks are also noted to be good for jewelry and as stocking stuffers due to their rich colors. Overall, they are considered a budget-friendly option for those in need of thin picks.

Key Features

  • Thickness: 0.46mm (Light/Thin)
  • Multicolored (in random)
  • Classic guitar pick shape
  • Provides natural feel and warm, round music tone
  • Material: Celluloid


  • Color: Multi-colored
  • Size: Pack of 12 – Assorted Colors


  • Good value for the price
  • Rich colors encourage practice time
  • Useful for jewelry and as stocking stuffers


  • Some picks may be too thin and flimsy
  • Colors received may not match those shown in pictures

The I-MART Stylish Colorful Celluloid Guitar Picks Plectrums offer a budget-friendly option for those in need of thin picks. While there are mixed reviews regarding their quality and appearance, they are appreciated for their value and usefulness as stocking stuffers and for jewelry.

Overall Score: 8/10

The Augshy 150 pc guitar pick sampler value pack offers a warm, round music tone suitable for guitar practice and professional use. The picks are made of quality material, flexible, durable, and lightweight. The ultra-thin 0.71mm thickness is suitable for fingers and provides a wonderful classic tone. The picks are ideal accessories for bass, ukulele, acoustic, or electric guitar. However, some users have mentioned a strong chemical odor and that the picks move around between fingers too much.

Key Features

  • Quantity: Offers 150 picks for guitar practice and professional use
  • Timbres: Thinness provides nice playing timbres ideal for guitar
  • Material: Made of quality ultra-thin, lightweight, and durable material
  • Function: Known for flexibility, durability, and finger protection
  • Application: Suitable for bass, ukulele, acoustic, or electric guitar


  • Color: Multicolor
  • Size: Medium


  • Good quality for the price
  • Great value with variety of thicknesses
  • Colorful blank picks for crafting


  • Strong chemical odor
  • Matte texture causes picks to move between fingers

The Augshy 150 Pcs Guitar Picks Sampler Value Pack is a solid choice for guitar enthusiasts looking for good quality at a reasonable price. The colorful picks offer a variety of thicknesses and are versatile for different playing preferences. However, the presence of a strong chemical odor and the matte texture causing movement between fingers may be a downside for some users.

Overall Score: 9/10

Experience comfort and high-performance flexibility with the Fender Premium Celluloid Guitar Picks. The traditional 351 shape and Celluloid material provide a familiar feel, smooth striking surface, warm musical tone, and ideal flexibility. The 12-pack picks are perfect for beginners and professionals, offering comfort and a quality playing experience. The Red Moto color adds a touch of style.

Key Features

  • Comfortable and familiar feel provided by the traditional 351 shape
  • Celluloid picks give the traditional feel, smooth striking surface, and warm, round musical tone
  • Medium gauge picks ideal for a warmer tone of a heavy pick and the flexibility of a thin pick
  • Comfort and high-performance flexibility for every performer
  • Convenient 12-pack for extended use and as gifts


  • Color: Red Moto
  • Dimension: 5.38Lx2.50Wx0.25H
  • Size: 12-Pack


  • Comfortable and familiar feel
  • Smooth striking surface and warm musical tone
  • Ideal flexibility for all players
  • Convenient 12-pack for extended use and as gifts
  • Red Moto color adds a stylish touch


  • Slightly hard to hold for some users
  • May not be suitable for electric guitar for some players

The Fender Premium Celluloid Guitar Picks offer a comfortable playing experience with a traditional feel, smooth surface, and warm tone. The 12-pack and Red Moto color make it a great value and a stylish choice for beginners and professionals alike.

Overall Score: 9/10

The Everly Guitar Picks (30022) are designed with a star-shaped grip to keep the pick securely at your fingertips while playing. They come in various sizes ranging from 50mm to 88mm. The picks are orange in color and have dimensions of 4.00Lx4.00Wx4.00H. Customers appreciate the enhanced grip provided by the star design, making it easier to hold and play without dropping the pick. Some users find the material too soft, affecting the tone and pick attack, while others love the comfortable feel and consistent sound quality. The star placement may be a hit or miss for some, but overall, the Everly Guitar Picks are praised for their durability and balanced features.

Key Features

  • Star-shaped grip keeps the pick right at your fingertips
  • Choose from sizes: 50mm, 60mm, 73mm, 88mm


  • Color: Orange
  • Dimension: 4.00Lx4.00Wx4.00H
  • Size: .60mm


  • Enhanced grip provided by star design
  • Comfortable and consistent sound quality
  • Durable material


  • Soft material may affect tone and pick attack
  • Star placement may not suit everyone's preferences

The Everly Guitar Picks (30022) offer a unique star-shaped grip and come in various sizes, catering to different preferences. While the soft material may not be for everyone, the picks boast durable construction and provide a comfortable, consistent sound quality. Whether for acoustic or electric guitar playing, these picks strike a good balance of features, making them a reliable choice for musicians.

Overall Score: 9/10

The JIM DUNLOP Variety Pack Guitar Picks is a selection of picks that offers a range of materials and gauges to suit different playing styles. The 12 pack includes picks made in the USA, providing a mix of textures and thicknesses to complement the tone and playability of acoustic instruments.

Key Features

  • A variety of picks to complement acoustic instruments
  • Includes different materials and gauges to fit different playing styles
  • 12 pack
  • Made in USA
  • Model Number: PVP112


  • Color: Multicolor
  • Dimension: 4.00Lx2.50Wx0.25H
  • Size: Small


  • Good variety of different kinds of picks
  • Great for beginners
  • Good value for the price
  • Nice assortment for experimenting with playing styles
  • Quality picks
  • Reasonable price


  • Quality issues – mold flashing and rough edges on some picks

The JIM DUNLOP Variety Pack Guitar Picks offers a fantastic range of picks suitable for various playing styles. It provides excellent value for the price, making it a great option for beginners and experienced players alike. Despite some quality issues on a few picks, the overall variety and quality make this pack a worthwhile investment.

Buyer's Guide: Guitar Picks

Types of Guitar Picks

  • Standard Picks: These are the most common picks, usually made of thin to medium gauge plastic.
  • Heavy Picks: Thicker and stiffer picks that produce a louder and more defined sound, often preferred by rock and metal guitarists.
  • Thin Picks: Great for strumming and producing a soft, mellow sound.


  • Plastic Picks: Affordable and widely available, come in a variety of thicknesses and colors.
  • Metal Picks: Produces a bright and sharp sound, but may wear out guitar strings faster.
  • Nylon Picks: Flexible and durable, great for producing a smooth, consistent sound.


  • Standard Shape: The most common pick shape, easy to hold and versatile for various playing styles.
  • Teardrop Shape: Offers a more precise and controlled grip, great for fingerpicking.
  • Triangular Shape: Provides more surface area for a better grip, ideal for fast strumming.


  • Thin Picks (0.38mm – 0.73mm): Ideal for strumming and creating a mellower tone.
  • Medium Picks (0.74mm – 0.88mm): Versatile and suitable for various playing styles.
  • Heavy Picks (0.90mm and above): Produces a louder and more defined sound, great for lead guitar playing.


  • Smooth Picks: Allows for quick and effortless strumming, but may slip out of your fingers.
  • Textured Picks: Provides a better grip and control, especially for intense playing.


  • Affordable Picks: Basic plastic picks are budget-friendly and come in various thicknesses and shapes.
  • Mid-Range Picks: Higher quality materials and unique designs, suitable for intermediate players.
  • Premium Picks: Handcrafted or specialty picks with unique materials, ideal for professional musicians.

Personal Preference

  • Playing Style: Consider the type of music you play and your playing technique.
  • Guitar Type: Certain picks may work better with specific guitar types such as acoustic or electric.
  • Comfort: Choose a pick that feels comfortable and easy to handle for extended playing sessions.


  • Plastic Picks: Can wear down over time with heavy use, but are easily replaceable.
  • Metal Picks: Highly durable but may cause faster wear on guitar strings.
  • Nylon Picks: Known for their longevity and ability to maintain their shape over time.

Custom Picks

  • Design: Custom picks can feature personalized artwork, logos, or text, adding a unique touch to your playing.
  • Materials: Custom picks can be made from various materials, allowing for a tailored playing experience.

Eco-Friendly Options

  • Recycled Materials: Picks made from recycled plastics or other eco-friendly materials.
  • Reusable Picks: Invest in durable picks that are designed to last, reducing the need for constant replacement.

Storage and Maintenance

  • Pick Holders: Keep your picks organized and easily accessible with a pick holder or keychain.
  • Cleaning: Regularly clean your picks to remove dirt, oils, and debris to maintain their performance.


  • Try Different Picks: Test out various types, shapes, and thicknesses to find the best fit for your playing style.
  • Ask for Recommendations: Seek advice from experienced guitarists or music store experts for personalized recommendations.

Additional Considerations

  • Grip Size: Consider the size of your hands and find picks that are comfortable to hold.
  • Packaging: Some picks come in convenient packaging, making them easy to store and transport.

Remember to consider your own playing style, musical preferences, and budget when choosing the right guitar picks for you. Experimentation and trying out different options can help you find the perfect match for your unique needs and preferences.

Frequently Asked Questions about Top Guitar Picks: A Comprehensive Review

What are guitar picks used for?

Guitar picks are used to strum or pluck the strings of a guitar. They create a clearer and more precise sound compared to using just your fingers.

How do I choose the right guitar pick for me?

The right guitar pick for you depends on your playing style and the type of music you like to play. Thicker picks are better for heavy strumming, while thinner picks are better for playing lead guitar.

Can I use a coin as a guitar pick?

While some people do use coins as makeshift guitar picks, it’s not recommended. Coins can damage the strings and affect the sound of the guitar.

Do different materials affect the sound of the guitar pick?

Yes, different materials such as plastic, metal, or even wood can all produce different sounds when used as guitar picks. Experimenting with different materials can help you find the sound you like best.

How do I hold a guitar pick properly?

To hold a guitar pick properly, place it between your thumb and index finger. Make sure only a small part of the pick is showing and keep a relaxed grip to avoid tension in your hand while playing.

Was this page helpful?