Home>Gift Ideas>Top Ice Cube Trays: A Comprehensive Review
Gift Ideas
Top Ice Cube Trays: A Comprehensive Review
Published: February 19, 2024
Discover the top ice cube trays for your needs with our comprehensive review. Find the perfect ice cube tray for your drinks and more.
(Many of the links in this article redirect to a specific reviewed product. Your purchase of these products through affiliate links helps to generate commission for Giftslessordinary.com, at no extra cost. Learn more)
Are you someone who loves to enjoy a cold beverage on a hot day or make fun ice cubes for a refreshing drink? If so, you're in for a treat! In this comprehensive review, we will take a closer look at some of the top ice cube trays available on the market. As a 10th grader, you'll find this guide helpful in choosing the best ice cube tray for your needs. Whether you're looking for durability, ease of use, or unique shapes, we've got you covered. So let's dive in and find the perfect ice cube tray for you!
Overall Score: 9.5/10
The Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin from Jrisbo is a set of 4 easy-release ice cube trays made from premium silicone and PP material. These BPA-free, stackable trays come with removable lids designed to save space in the freezer. The silicone bottom makes it effortless to get 14 perfect ice cubes. The kit also includes an ice container, ice tong, scoop, and 4 stainless steel straws. Customer ratings for this product are at an impressive 4.6/5.
Key Features
- Effortless to Release
- Stackable & Removable Lid
- Food Grade Safety Material
- Easy to Use
- Includes Additional Ice Accessories
Specifications
- Color: 4-in-1 Kit Green
- Dimension: 9.00Lx3.00Wx1.00H
- Size: 10 x 6 x 1.4 inches
Pros
- Easy to release ice cubes
- Removable, stackable lids
- Food grade and BPA-free material
- Comes with additional accessories
Cons
- Trays do not stack without lids
The Jrisbo Ice Cube Tray Kit is a convenient and efficient solution for making ice cubes. The effortlessness of releasing the ice cubes from the tray, along with the ability to stack them in the freezer and the addition of extra accessories, makes this kit highly recommended. The minor issue of needing to use the lids to stack the trays is a minor trade-off for the overall quality and functionality of the product.
Overall Score: 9/10
The DOQAUS Ice Cube Trays 4 Pack is made of premium silicone and PP material. It is LFGB certified and BPA free. The easy-release design and spill-resistant removable lid make it perfect for making ice cubes for baby food, cocktails, and coffee. Each tray makes up to 56 ice cubes and is dishwasher safe.
Key Features
- Made of premium silicone and PP material
- LFGB certified and BPA free
- Spill-resistant removable lid
- Stackable and dishwasher safe
Specifications
- Color: Green
- Dimension: 10.00Lx4.13Wx3.00H
- Size: 10*4.1*3 inches
Pros
- LFGB certified and BPA free
- Easy-release design
- Dishwasher safe
Cons
- Brittle lid lifter tabs
- Instructions for fill line unclear
The DOQAUS Ice Cube Trays 4 Pack is a strong, safe, and convenient solution for making ice cubes. The easy-release design and spill-resistant lid make it a great companion for daily use. However, the brittle lid lifter tabs and unclear fill line instructions are minor drawbacks. Overall, it’s a highly recommended product for anyone looking for durable, easy-to-use ice cube trays.
Overall Score: 8/10
The DclobTop Stackable Round Ice Cube Tray Set is the ultimate space saver, designed to make ice balls or various ice fruit balls. Crafted from premium quality BPA-free and food grade PP materials, this ice tray set is guaranteed to give you odor-free and untainted ice cubes. The stackable design ensures maximum freezer efficiency, and the storage container keeps your ice cubes organized and your refrigerator neat. This set can make 99 round ice balls, adding a touch of creativity to your cocktails, beverages, and coffee. The ice trays are easy to fill and easy to use. However, the tray can be a bit flimsy and may not hold up for long.
Key Features
- Ultimate Space Saver
- Interesting finds
- Premium Quality Assured
- Effortless Ice Release
- Versatility at its Best
Specifications
- Color: Blue
- Dimension: 11.00Lx7.08Wx4.50H
- Size: Large
Pros
- Convenient and good quality
- Great for making a lot of ice at once
- Great design
- Perfect for your icing needs
- Easy to use
- Cute cubes
Cons
- Flimsy tray
- Container may arrive broken
The DclobTop Stackable Round Ice Cube Tray Set offers a convenient, space-saving solution for creating unique round ice balls for your drinks and cocktails. It’s easy to use and helps you keep your freezer organized. However, the flimsy tray and the possibility of the container arriving broken are points to consider. Overall, it’s a great addition to any home bar.
Overall Score: 9/10
The DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin is a 4 pack of silicone and plastic ice cube trays for the freezer. The trays come with a storage ice bucket, ice tong, and ice scoop. They are easy to use and dishwasher safe. The silicone and plastic material make it easy to remove ice, and the lids prevent spills and freezing excess water. The trays also stack easily and neatly in the freezer without sticking. These trays are perfect for homes, parties, bars, and make a great gift.
Key Features
- Stronger & Safety: Made of premium silicone and PP material
- Easy Ice Removal: TPE material with wider bottom design
- Easy to Use & Dishwasher Safe: Fill, cover, and freeze
- Lids Lifter Designed: Convenient removable lids with lifters
- Good Customer Service: Responsive and willing to provide solutions
Specifications
- Color: Green
- Dimension: 10.79Lx6.14Wx3.74H
- Size: 4 Pack
Pros
- Strong and durable material
- Easy to use and clean
- Lids prevent spills and freezer odors
- Responsive customer service
Cons
- Lid not as sturdy as trays
- Fill line on tray not easily visible
- Small and useless ice tongs
The DOQAUS Ice Cube Tray with Lid and Bin is a versatile and durable set of ice trays that make ice making a breeze. With sturdy construction, lids to prevent spills, and a convenient ice box, this product offers great value for money. It’s perfect for small spaces and is a must-have for any party or gathering.
Overall Score: 8/10
The Ice Cube Trays for Freezer with Lid is a must-have kitchen accessory for ice coffee lovers. This 37 grid silicone ice cube tray makes perfect small ice cubes for cocktails and iced coffee. The user-friendly design and durable silicone material with a lid make it easy to release ice cubes while preventing spills and freezer odors. It's also suitable for emergency ice and great for RV travel. The product is dishwasher safe and perfect for gifting.
Key Features
- 37 Grid Ice Trays for Freezer with Lid
- Ice Cube Mold Release Easily
- Small Ice Cube Trays with Lid Design
- Ice Coffee Lovers Must Haves
- New Home Essentials Reusable Ice Cubes for Drinks
- Easy to Use & Dishwasher Safe
- Crushed Ice for Sugar Dessert
- Reusable Ice Cubes for Emergency Needs
- Great for RV Travel
- Perfect Gifts for You
Specifications
- Color: Blue
- Dimension: 8.26Lx4.64Wx0.82H
- Size: 1 Pack
Pros
- Easy to use and dishwasher safe
- Perfect size for iced coffee
- Great for RV travel and emergency ice
- Durable silicone material with a lid
- User-friendly design
Cons
- Challenging to fill without spilling
- Cover doesn't stay on securely
The Ice Cube Trays for Freezer with Lid offers a convenient and efficient way to make small ice cubes, perfect for iced coffee and cocktails. While there are challenges with filling and securing the cover, the durability, ease of use, and practicality of this product make it a kitchen essential.
Overall Score: 7/10
The Ice Cube Tray, 4Pcs Silicone Easy-Release 14-Ice Cube Trays is a versatile product made from food-grade safe materials. It features effortless ice cube release and stackable, removable lids. This product is perfect for family gatherings, parties, and bars, as well as for making ice cream, jelly, and chocolates. The colorful designs provide a fun ice-making experience. However, some customers found the ice cubes to be small and had issues with the product's size and durability.
Key Features
- Food-Grade Safe Materials: High-quality silicone and PP materials
- Effortless Release: Flexible silicone material with push mechanism
- Stackable and Removable Lid: Prevents odor tainting and frost formation
- Versatile Use: 4 trays, each with 14 cubes, for a total of 56 cubes
- Muti Colors&DIY Craft Enthusiasts: Enjoyable ice-making experience
Specifications
- Color: 4Pcs Silicone Ice Cube Trays
- Dimension: 11.81Lx3.15Wx1.18H
Pros
- Made from high-quality food-grade safe materials
- Effortless ice cube release
- Versatile use for various frozen treats
- Fun and colorful designs for a joyful ice-making experience
Cons
- Some customers found the ice cubes to be small
- Issues with product's size and durability
The Ice Cube Tray, 4Pcs Silicone Easy-Release 14-Ice Cube Trays is a convenient and versatile product, with easy-to-use features and a colorful design. However, some customers experienced issues with the ice cube size and product’s durability. Overall, it provides a practical solution for creating ice cubes and other frozen treats for various occasions.
Overall Score: 9/10
The FDDBI Ice Cube Tray is perfect for creating large ice cubes for whiskey and cocktails. This 2-pack silicone tray is designed for easy ice cube removal and comes with a tight-fitting lid to keep ice fresh. The food-grade silicone trays are versatile and ideal for parties, restaurants, and more.
Key Features
- Easy release large ice cube tray
- Cocktail ice cube tray with lid
- Large whiskey ice cubes
- Food-grade silicone ice cube tray
- Versatile old fashioned ice cube tray
Specifications
- Color: Black(2 pack)
- Dimension: 6.20Lx3.80Wx1.80H
- Size: Large
Pros
- Easy to release ice cubes
- Comes with lid for freshness
- Versatile for various drinks and food
- Food-grade material
- Ideal for parties and entertaining
Cons
- Design may make it hard to release cubes
- Thin plastic in individual compartments
The FDDBI Ice Cube Tray offers a convenient and versatile solution for creating large ice cubes for drinks and freezing food portions. With its easy release design and food-grade silicone material, it’s a great addition to any bar or kitchen.
Overall Score: 9/10
The Ice Cube Trays are made of food-grade silicone and PP material, and are 100% BPA free. They are perfect for home and bar use, easy to clean and store, and ensure easy ice removal. The 2-pack ice cube trays are stackable with removable lids, offering a space-saving solution. With a customer rating of 4.4/5, they have received positive reviews for their functionality and ease of use.
Key Features
- Made of food-grade silicone and PP material
- Perfect for home and bar use
- Easy to clean and store
- Ensure easy ice removal
- Comes in a stackable 2-pack with removable lids
Specifications
- Color: Green/White
- Dimension: 10.10Lx4.14Wx2.64H
Pros
- Multipurpose use for home and bar
- Easily removable ice cubes
- Stackable and space-saving design
- Positive customer ratings and reviews
Cons
- Silicone inserts are yielding and may cause spillage
- Lids made of thin, cheap, brittle plastic
The Ice Cube Trays provide a convenient and efficient solution for making and storing ice cubes at home or in a bar setup. With their durable and easy-to-clean design, they offer great value for their price and are highly recommended for those looking for a versatile ice cube solution.
Overall Score: 7/10
The ZDPMK Silicone Ice Cube Trays are high-quality and safe to use. It has 15 cavities, allowing you to make large, slow-melting square ice cubes that are perfect for cooling your drinks. The trays are extremely versatile, easy to clean, and make a great gift. It comes in blue color and measures 7.30Lx4.60Wx1.30H. However, some users have mentioned a petroleum smell and difficulty in removing the ice cubes. Overall, it's a practical and versatile product that is perfect for any occasion.
Key Features
- High-quality and safe to use
- 15 cavities for large, slow-melting square ice cubes
- Extremely versatile and easy to clean
- Great as a gift
- Customer service guarantee
Specifications
- Color: Blue
- Dimension: 7.30Lx4.60Wx1.30H
Pros
- High-quality silicone material
- Large, slow-melting ice cubes
- Versatile and easy to clean
- Great for gifting
- Customer service guarantee
Cons
- Some users mentioned a petroleum smell
- Difficulty in removing the ice cubes
The ZDPMK Silicone Ice Cube Trays are practical and versatile, making them perfect for various occasions. While it has some drawbacks, the overall quality and functionality of the trays make them a great addition to any kitchen or bar. With these trays, you can create large, slow-melting ice cubes that are perfect for keeping your drinks cold without diluting them too quickly. Despite some user concerns, the product offers great value for its price.
Overall Score: 9/10
The Kitch Ice Tray Easy Release White Ice Cube Trays is the perfect solution for creating ice cubes at home. Proudly made in the USA, these ice trays are made of top-quality food-grade materials, ensuring durability and flexibility. Each tray makes 16 good-sized ice cubes, and the pack includes 2 trays for a total of 32 cubes. These trays are stackable, BPA-free, and dishwasher safe. Customers have praised these trays for their ease of use, sturdiness, and perfect size of the ice cubes produced. The ice cubes can be easily released and they do not refreeze to the plastic, ensuring hassle-free use. However, there have been rare concerns about quality control issues. Overall, the Kitch Ice Tray Easy Release White Ice Cube Trays are a simple and effective solution for making ice at home.
Key Features
- MADE IN THE USA: Proudly made in the USA out of top quality food grade materials. Each purchase supports American industry and factory workers
- INCLUDES 2 ICE CUBE TRAYS! Each tray makes 16 nice-sized ice cubes for a total of 32
- FLEXIBLE AND DURABLE ICE TRAYS: Ice cubes release easily with just a twist
- STACKABLE: Trays stack easily and neatly in the freezer without sticking to each other
- BPA FREE AND DISHWASHER SAFE: These Kitch Ice Trays are 100% BPA Free and safe to wash in the dishwasher
Specifications
- Color: White
- Dimension: 12.00Lx4.50Wx3.00H
- Size: (2 Pack – 32 Cubes)
Pros
- Made in the USA
- Easy to release ice cubes
- Sturdy and stackable
- BPA-free and dishwasher safe
Cons
- Rare quality control issues
The Kitch Ice Tray Easy Release White Ice Cube Trays offer a simple and effective solution for making ice cubes at home. Proudly made in the USA, these trays are durable, flexible, and produce perfect ice cubes. While there have been rare quality control concerns, the majority of customers have praised the ease of use and sturdiness of these ice trays. Overall, these trays are a great addition to any kitchen and offer great value for home ice-making needs.
Ice Cube Trays Buyer's Guide
- Material
- Plastic:
- Durable and lightweight
- Can crack or warp over time
- Can have a plastic smell
- Silicone:
- Flexible and easy to pop out ice
- Can be more expensive
- Can absorb odors if not washed properly
- Metal:
- Fast freezing
- Can transfer metallic taste to ice
- Can be difficult to remove ice
- Shape
- Traditional Cube:
- Good for everyday use
- Can take up more space in the freezer
- Spheres:
- Melts slower for drinks
- Takes longer to freeze
- Unique Shapes:
- Fun and creative
- May not fit into all water bottles
- Size
- Standard:
- Fits most glasses and pitchers
- Can be too small for large drinks
- Large:
- Ideal for cocktails and punches
- Takes up more space in the freezer
- Small:
- Great for portion control
- Can melt quickly in large drinks
- Ease of Use
- Stackable:
- Saves space in the freezer
- Can be difficult to separate when stacked
- Flexible:
- Easy to pop out ice
- May require a tray underneath to prevent spilling
- Additional Features
- Lids:
- Prevent spills and odors from the freezer
- Can be bulky and hard to store
- Easy Fill:
- Quick and mess-free filling
- May require a steady hand
- Dishwasher Safe:
- Easy cleaning and maintenance
- Some materials may degrade over time in the dishwasher
- Price
- Budget-Friendly:
- Affordable for everyday use
- May not last as long
- Mid-Range:
- Good balance of quality and price
- Can vary in durability
- High-End:
- Premium materials and features
- May not be necessary for basic ice needs
- Factors to Consider
- Frequency of Use:
- Consider how often you'll be using the ice cube trays
- Space in Freezer:
- Ensure the trays will fit in your freezer
- Types of Drinks:
- Consider the size and shape of ice needed for specific drinks
- Maintenance Tips
- Regular Cleaning:
- Prevents odors and build-up
- Use warm water and mild soap
- Proper Storage:
- Keep trays flat or stacked with a barrier
- Prevents spills and odors
- Inspect for Damage:
- Replace trays if they show signs of wear and tear
- Ensure the ice is safe to consume
Remember, the best ice cube tray for you will depend on your specific needs and preferences. Consider the material, shape, size, ease of use, additional features, price, and maintenance when choosing the right ice cube tray for you.
Frequently Asked Questions about Top Ice Cube Trays: A Comprehensive Review
An average ice cube tray can typically make 12 to 16 ice cubes at one time.
Yes, most ice cube trays are dishwasher safe and can be easily cleaned in the top rack of the dishwasher.
Yes, there are various sizes of ice cube trays available including standard size for most freezers, extra-large for bigger ice cubes, and novelty shapes like hearts or stars.
Absolutely! You can use an ice cube tray to freeze things like coffee for iced coffee, juice for flavored ice cubes, or herbs in olive oil for cooking.
You should replace your ice cube tray if it becomes cracked, warped, or if the individual compartments no longer freeze properly. On average, a good quality ice cube tray can last for several years.
